Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Three and a Half Defencemen to Consider for Ottawa's Stretch Run

After Murray got the ball rolling last week with the Cullen acquisition, it is widely expected that the team will look at picking up a defenceman to round out the roster for the stretch run. We needed a bit more scoring so we waived Cheechoo and replaced him with Cullen. Our goaltending is what it is - Elliott will ride it out until he falters or Pascal somehow takes his job back.

With the departure of Picard, the injury to Campoli (Karlsson will be back after the break), and the inability of Lee to keep his job, we could use another body back there to make sure we maintain our depth. I have been reading the comments elsewhere that we should get higher end guys like Kubina, Ballard, Robidas, Burns, etc. Guys, let's give our heads a shake. Whoever we acquire is a pure rental and we aren't going to give up more than a 2nd round pick (and maybe Lee, if someone will take him). Ballard and Robidas are signed to long-term extensions and are key pieces of their team's blueline. Burns is too young and valuable for Minnesota to give up on, as well. Kubina is a guy that would be nice, but I just don't think he could be had for just a second round pick and I don't think we want to throw in a decent prospect to even it up.

I think we're looking more at a bottom end defenceman that is an impending UFA, out of the race, and won't cost an arm and a leg to acquire for the remainder of the season. Three options are right here:

1. Dennis Seidenberg, Florida Panthers.

Nothing spectacular, 22 points in 61 games and a minus-1 on a bad team. He isn't huge and isn't an overwhelming presence, but he does his job. He's someone that you could drop into the 5-6 pairing and not miss a beat. Florida has said they are cleaning house and there really is no reason to think Seidenberg isn't going to be available. Moore netted them a second rounder from the Habs and so I think Seidenberg couldn't cost more than that. This is just a simple depth move. I'm aware that Eklund mentioned it on his blog today and he's usually out to lunch with Sens rumours, but this one is at least worth noting.

2. Andy Sutton, New York Islanders

This is simply a big dude. He has had some injury problems over his career and he has basically zero playoff experience, but he's huge. If we are worried about being pushed around in the playoff run, then this is the guy. That being said, we're already icing Phillips, Volchenkov, and Carkner as defensive players out there, so this might be overkill and hurt us in puck movement. He's a good ole Kingston boy that has been stuck in the Isles system for a while and maybe they are ready to part with him, plus we know Murray has worked with Garth in deadline deals. I'm just not sure Sutton is exactly what we'd need, but he is NHL caliber and can hit a dude into the 10th row, if we need it.

3. Milan Jurcina, Columbus Blue Jackets

If you are looking for points, keep looking elsewhere. Jurcina, like Sutton, is a huge guy that can hit hard and clear bodies. The catch here is that the Jackets just acquired him a few months ago from the Caps when he and Chris Clark were traded for Jason Chimera. Jurcina is basically a cheaper, younger version of Sutton. The Jackets are out of the playoffs and again, we've worked with them before in trades. Jurcina should be available as he isn't really a part of the long-term plans in Columbus. If we don't mind parting with that second rounder, Jurcina would be a cheap guy to pick up and fill a hole in a tougher series where maybe Campoli doesn't have the strength.

I guess it really depends on what type of defenceman we need, right? I've named off some defensive guys because they always seem to cost a bit less as far as trade returns. One other name that will get me laughed off the Internet is Mathieu Schneider out of Vancouver, who is currently coming back from injury in the minors. He's 40 years old, but he's a warrior that has seen it all and could be a nice 7th defenceman that we could plug in to run the second powerplay unit. There's no role for him in Vancouver and could either be had on re-entry waivers or via trade. Again, we're looking for a low end guy that can play 5-6 minutes in case someone gets hurt. Depth move.

We have two weeks to think about it while we watch our boys go for Gold in Vancouver. After that, Murray has less than a week to pull the trigger. If the two games over the weekend are any indication, we probably need to get something done that helps us from having to drop Lee back in there during the playoffs.

15 comments:

Master Of Puppets said...

I think the options you've mentioned are strong possibilities. Schneider as a rental for 15 minutes a game with PP duty is probably viable. But as a vet he probably would expect 20+ minutes.

Kubina would be a good swap for Kuba straight up. I think he actually hits. That only fixes one area and doesn't add depth.

I like MMs brother too. Solid and cheap if the yotes would part with him. But in all likelihood not as a rental - I'd trade Lee and a pick for him and re-sign for 1.5M+ if it could be done.

Anonymous said...

I'm still not done with Lee. He did not have a bad game against New York. I think he would prove himself as a versatile all around guy that should be a 7th for the playoffs. I don't know who I would rather have as that 7th - Lee or Campoli. I figure we either trade for a faster, more offensive D for the 5-6 position that is an upgrade on Campoli, - and therefore move Camps. Or get a more defensive guy that is an upgrade on Lee, and trade Lee IMO.

Anonymous said...

this may not be popular ..
but can't somebody like Tom Preissing be signed/traded for on a two way deal ?

Anonymous said...

Why do you guys always talk about trading the non-tradeables...no one wants Lee Or Campy or our lessor forwards (#18, #26, #41) or any of our guys in Bingo. So it's draft picks and good players for any good D-man (1. Kabina = the Cup finals; 2. Sutton = the Conference finals.) Bryan will not bite on this...so the big moves are over!

However, you guys were sleeping during the strategy meetings again...it's next year, "Eugene/Bryan Plan 10/11!" put some bums in the seats with another two big good young DEFENCEMEN!

Anshu said...

Once we get Karlsson back, our D will be pretty good. It'll be tough to get a rental that's an obvious upgrade.

In the case of Cheechoo, taking him out made for an opportunity to clearly upgrade our offensive lineup while preserving depth. Since he was of so little value, getting someone better was not a huge challenge. We still have guys like Winchester and Donovan that can be injury fill-ins as necessary.

On the defensive side, its not so clear cut. I don't think any of the names you mention are an upgrade over Campoli. So does it really make sense to bring in a guy to be our 7th d-man if it means giving up a 2nd rounder or more? Not to me it doesn't.

A 3rd or 4th rounder maybe. But I would be loathe to give up anything of real value just to get a bit of injury insurance.

BTW, I agree with you about the national anthem. Should not have done the re-mix for all the reasons you mentioned.

Anonymous said...

My two cents.. I dont think we expected to be this close this year, but given the east I think we have to go for it. Of those options, I must say Sutton.. I remember 2007 and getting made finger puppets ( not the nice kind!) of Anaheim in the finals. heck they have the cap space now to get Schneider as well.. Unless a blockbuster for Neidermeyer catches us off guard you may as well load up with a pounding defence. Carks and Sutton back there would finaly make life terrible for opposing forwards in our own end.

GelatinousMutantCoconut said...

SJ's second for Seidenberg.

Dallas's Sixth for Tolleffson

Phillips-Karlsson
Seidenberg-Volchenkov
Kuba-Carkner
Campoli-Tolleffson

Anonymous said...

What's Up Peeps

I Found This great resource on [url=http://hubpages.com/hub/Choosing-an-Entertainment-Unit-by-MilesgershonCom][b]Entertainment Unit[/b][/url]

Hope you enjoy learning from it as much as I did.

Cheers

Bob

Anonymous said...

[url=http://shoppharm.com]Online drugstore[/url].
On my surprise it works excellent! All the matter is that the price low, because I do not pay for the trade mark. That's all!
You can see explanations about it.
A generic drug (generic drugs, short: generics) is a drug which is produced and distributed without patent protection. According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, generic drugs are identical bioequivalent range to the brand name counterpart with respect to pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties. By extension, therefore, generics are considered identical in dose, strength, route of administration, safety, efficacy, and intended use. In most cases, generic products are available once the patent protections afforded to the original developer have expired. When generic products become available, the market competition often leads to substantially lower prices for both the original brand name product and the generic forms.

Anonymous said...

Hey Wassup?
I've been around here for a while now, and I finally found something worth writing about: I found a great deal on custom [url=http://www.milesgershon.com][b] Wood Entertainment Centers[/b][/url]. These guys have 24/7 call-in service and they installed AND delivered my custom [url=http://www.milesgershon.com][b] Wall Mount tv Cabinets [/b][/url]all for Free!!! I just bought from them, and I've never had a more seamless internet buy -they ACTUALLY called me to confirm the order and talk about delivery time… unreal!

Peace

Anonymous said...

Hey Wassup?
I've been around here for a while now, and I finally found something worth writing about: I found a great deal on custom [url=http://www.milesgershon.com][b] Wood Entertainment Centers[/b][/url]. These guys have 24/7 call-in service and they installed AND delivered my custom [url=http://www.milesgershon.com][b] Wall Mount tv Cabinets [/b][/url]all for Free!!! I just bought from them, and I've never had a more seamless internet buy -they ACTUALLY called me to confirm the order and talk about delivery time… unreal!

L8r

Anonymous said...

Hello People

I found an SWEET site last night when I was surfing with my boyfriend. Check out this [url=http://www.girlsteachguys.com/PlayVideo.aspx?LiveClip=54][b] Sex Positions [/b][/url] Video I found there.

Hope this helps folks here wanting to try something new… LOL

L8r

Janice

Anonymous said...

Hello People

I found an AMAZING site last night when I was surfing with my boyfriend. Check out this [url=http://www.girlsteachguys.com/PlayVideo.aspx?LiveClip=54][b] Sex Positions [/b][/url] Video I found there.

Hope this helps folks here wanting to try something new… LOL

Enjoy

Janice

Anonymous said...

Hey

I wanted to share with you a great site I just came across teaching [url=http://www.kravmagabootcamp.com][b]Krav Maga[/b][/url] like they teach it in the Israeli Army (IDF) If you guys have seen the Discovery Channel TV Show called Fight Quest you would have seen their chief instructor Ran Nakash there featured on their [url=http://www.kravmagabootcamp.com][b]Krav Maga[/b][/url] episode. Anyways, let me know what you think. Is training via the internet something you would do?


all the best

Joe

Anonymous said...

Saved as a favorite, I love your web site!

Here is my website workouts to improve vertical jump