Wednesday, September 16, 2009

5 Minute Major - Q&A with TSN heartthrob James Duthie

Ahh, what a relief that hockey season is back upon us, we're talking about forward lines, and the summer of hell in Ottawa is over. Instead of dissecting last night's scrub loss to the Panthers, we're going to feature our third installment of of 'Five Minute Major' series of interviews. Today's exclusive is with TSN's James Duthie, Ottawa native and host of NHL on TSN.

If you're looking for our previous installments, they're here:
John Buccigross interview is here
James Cybulski interview is here

But this is all about Duthie! James Duthie is an Ottawa native and a graduate of Carleton University. He has received three nominations for Gemini Awards as 'Best Host or Interviewer in a Sports Program or Sportscast', as well as a nomination for hosting the six-hour 'Canada's Game - Hockey Lives Here' feature. In addition to being the current host and instigator on NHL on TSN, he continues to write a piece for the Ottawa Citizen called 'the Good, the Bad, and the Duthie'.

Another Sens Blog was able to capture lightning in a bottle, also known as a one-on-one with JD before the hockey season gets fully underway and he spends his nights with the panelists on TSN. Here's the interview in full. Enjoy. And a big shout out to Duthie, who insists that this is now his homepage!

Another Sens Blog: James, thanks for chatting with us. Let's jump right in with the current affairs: Michalek and Cheechoo for Heatley. We know who the best player in the deal was, but can you argue that Ottawa still made out well in this trade, either with the 'addition through subtraction' cliche or by getting some scoring depth?

James Duthie: You can never "win" a trade like this, when you deal your top scorer, and one of the best in the league--but they did better than I thought they would--considering Murray didn't just have a gun to his head--he had an Uzi. Getting Michalek in the deal was big--and Cheechoo may not get 50 ever again, but he shouldn't get 12 again either.

ASB: So the return was decent given the circumstances and gives us more depth. Is this forward corps now balanced enough to pose a different threat than the past years of being a one line team?

JD: Yes, definitely more balance so it is a different threat. And as a unit, I think they are better. Don't forget Kelly and Fisher can't possibly have that poor offensive years again. But that top line has still taken a hit, and when a game is on the line...and on PP, he'll still be missed.

ASB: I appreciate you not using "his" name. Let's talk blueline. Bryan Murray hasn't gotten his elite defenceman, either as a top flight puck mover or a #1 physical presence. Is this blueline close to what it was three years ago in the Finals?

JD: No--I don't think its close. I think Karlsson will be really good someday...but not yet. This group is decent...but not near the group in 07 that was among the league's best--at least for that year.

ASB: And now the most important position for us. We all realize that we're only as good as our goalie. Is Pascal Leclaire the real-deal with a great attitude or is he a younger, injury-prone Gerber that isn't worth his salary? How critical is his success to this team?

JD: He's had a rough couple of years, but I don't think "injury-prone" is fair...yet. I'd take Leclaire over Gerber any day. If he's healthy, it's the best goalie they've had since...umm...uhh...errr....ever? Okay Tugnutt on that first playoff run was pretty good...and Lalime was good in the regular season. Besides them...I got nuthin'. Leclaire has to steal about 7 games for them to make the playoffs.

ASB: Scary since we've rarely had goalies 'steal' games for us. Hasek was capable of it, but...adductor...ahhhh! What about the coach? Cory Clouston - coach of the year candidate or gone by the deadline? Is this guy the coach of the future for us or did he just get lucky last spring?

JD: I liked what I saw, but who knows. The three previous coaches they've had over the past year and a half are all good hockey men, and they all failed miserably with (essentially) this group. At some point you say coaching isn't the problem here. If he gets fired by the deadline...I can't see how its Murray doing the firing. No GM gets to change coaches that many times without getting fired himself. (Except maybe my buddy Milbury during his Long Island days!). I think Clouston will do well and be around a while (which in Ottawa means beyond one year).

ASB: Great pot shot at Milbury! Tell us about AK27. Will the real Alex Kovalev please stand up? Will we love him or hate him by Christmas?

JD: You will love him by Halloween. Hate him by Remembrance Day. Love him by American Thanksgiving. Hate him by Christmas. Love him by New Year' get my drift. He won't change...he never has in his career. He'll be great some nights and invisible others. Guaranteed.

ASB: Same question was asked of C-Balls - why does Toronto hate Alfie? Jealousy or pure hatred?

JD: I refuse to answer questions C-Balls has been asked. It belittles me. Just kidding C-balls. I guess it all goes back to that "guarantee" of winning the Cup...which he did in an interview with me...and if you had been was hardly a brash bold cocky prediction...he was just trying to show a little confidence. Then there was that mock throw of stick into crowd thing a few years back...which was actually funny... so basically all the reasons are lame. Alfie remains one of my favourite players in the league--works his butt off every night--I think they probably hate him because they wished they had more players like him. So jealousy mostly--although I think that has died down a lot.

ASB: I knew it! Refreshing to hear that Alfie is also well-liked in media circles. Future mayor of Ottawam. Okay, let's hit the third period: Playoffs - make your prediction. Where are we in late April...late May...?

JD: I think they might make it...but dogfight for 7th or 8th...and probably an early exit...unless Leclaire walks on water.

ASB: Who wears more on-air makeup: Mike Milbury or Pierre McGuire?

JD: Neither wears much--i probably wear more than both---a whole lotta ugly to cover up--but Pierre has a lot of head to powder.

ASB: You were just awarded an NHL expansion franchise (Balsillie is furious that you won out over him). Who is your GM, who is your head coach, and what is the one player in this league that you'd love to build your team around?

JD: If I couldn't lure Ken Holland away from Detroit, then I'd try to steal David Poile from Nashville. How the Preds compete year after year with budget and ownership issues is unreal. If all employed GM's are off the list, Stevie Y is my guy. I think he'd bring good people in under him. My coach is Laviolette (I know, sounds like bias since I've worked with him...but I just like the guy and his philosophy, and there aren't unemployed guys out there who have won rings in the last five years).
My players are obvious: Sid or Ovie, I'll take either...but since those are boring answers, I'll say Mike Richards....because I think he's going to be the best leader in hockey for the next decade. Can I have Toews too? Didn't think so.

ASB: Awesome. I'm curious myself if Stevie Y will ever work his way into the Sens organization just because waiting on Holland in Detroit would be like waiting on Gehrig to give up first base. And one personal one for you - you've been at this for a long time and probably been at some amazing sporting events. That being said, you've still gotta be a fan of sports just like the rest of us. What are some of your best memories in broadcasting?

JD: Number one would have to meeting Cybulski for the first time.
After that...
The first Stanley Cup final game in Ottawa in 07 was cool, just because it was where I grew up, and started my career, so there was a Disney Circle of Life thing going on. And last year's World Junior gold medal game there was equally goose-bumping. Outside of hockey,
I covered all four golf majors the year of the lockout--that was amazing. Seeing Augusta had always been a dream, and watching Jack Nicklaus walk up the 18th fairway at St. Andrews for the last time, with old Scottish guys weeping all around me was unforgettable. And I was in Oakland for that Vince Carter slam dunk contest where he just went OFFFF!. Most electric atmosphere I've ever been a part of. (And doing this blog for you has to be in the top five).

ASB: Sweet, top five! And it is also cool to hear that you still have that passion and pride for Ottawa sports. One last time, thanks again for joining us. Classic stuff, especially the kind words for Alfie, the shout out to Cybulski, and the reminder that Milbury had some wild times on Long Island.

My sincere thanks to James for spending some time with us. I don't think he really needs our plug, but don't forget to check out his work in the Citizen and on NHL on TSN.

Let us know what you think. Is the defence that bad? Is our offence that good? Leclaire potentially our best goalie?


Anshu said...

I think there's a lot of pseudo-revisionist history related to the Sens defence the year they went to the finals. As I recall, we had in the top 6:

Phillips - shutdown guy, still here
Volchenkov - shot blocker/hitter, still here
Redden - supposed puck mover, gone
Meszaros - major defensive liability, gone
Corvo - small dynamic skater, gone
Preissing - small offensive d-man, gone

Not exactly a group that on paper would inspire much fear. The knock on that group was that they weren't physical enough, so the Sens have acquired guys to bring more grit to the D - Commodore and Smith in particular, while keeping our shutdown guys in Phillips and Volchenkov.

The result has been a considerably worse team.

Kuba, Campoli, Karlsson, Lee/Picard are probably as good as the guys we went to the Cup finals with, and are similarly offensive minded.

Muckler built this team like you would a fantasy team in a hockey pool and got us within a few wins of a Cup. We're a lot more like that again this year.

Grinder said...

Nice job Duff. This blog is the best of a growing list. There is more intelligent content and conversation here than almost anywhere.

On the topic of comparing 2007 to today... I actually watched a game from the 2007 playoffs against Pitt last night (on the NHL network). The Sens D was actually very solid, but there is no doubt that some guys, like Preissing and Corvo, were playing beyond their usual level of talent.

Furthermore, guys like Fisher and Neil were obviously having a nice run and seemed pumped. In that game, Kelly potted a nice goal and reminded me how we were getting production from everyone, not just the top line.

2008 was a whole other story. Our secondary players went to sleep and our D was ssslllloooowww.

I disagree however with Anon 9:22that the list of players on our D staff today is nearly as good as in 2007... Simply not true.

Kuba is good, but Karlsson isn't even a legit NHLer yet, Lee is brain dead and makes more mental mistakes than Mez and Corvo combined, Picard has lots of potential but as yet hasn't demonstrated much. Campoli is the one I like best and has excellent upside... Furthermore, Volchenkov is starting to feel all those blocked shots and Phillips is yet another year older and still won't hit a soul.

If anything, I think our D remains our biggest liability.

To call these guys good will get Canucknik going for sure LOL! Yikes...

Anonymous said...

I like how he skipped the whole Yzerman to Ottawa question ;D lol

Anshu said...

I disagree however with Anon 9:22that the list of players on our D staff today is nearly as good as in 2007... Simply not true.

My point is that the D in 2007 weren't that good either, but their style of play complemented the rest of the team well and they had a great run.

The only one of the guys that are gone that I'd like to have back is Corvo. But he's emotionally unstable, so that wasn't an option for Murray.

And there is no way any D-man on the team today is a bigger defensive liability than Mezsaros. Someone should put together a YouTube montage of every time Mez pinched in at the blueline and the other team's forward simply chipped the puck off the boards around him and got a 2-on-1 the other way. Seems like that happened twice a game for the entire time Mez was with the Sens...

Canucnik said...


A couple things:

I got the puck you don't! We haven't seen the puck for a year and a half...that's your "D"'s fault.

Always remember Mez was luggin' #6 every shift...Andre becomes a premiere defenceman and earns his bread in Tampa.

Our American League Defence shall lose it's name tag when #4 and #24 return to form; Philippe is in the 5-6 pairing and Erik and Alexandre are your top pair...could be xmas...could be next year.

Grinder said...


I certainly can't disagree with a lot of what you said, especially the part about the D being more coordinated to the forwards. On that point, we see eye to eye.

I also agree with Canucnik that Mez got a raw deal having been stuck with Redden during the slow dance of his demise.

All in all however, our current D is far from top shelf, even if 2007's was a bit overrated.

CJL said...

i dont really have a problem with our d in the sense that its set up pretty well for a transition in the next few years. the future of the defense has never been brighter with karlsson, cowen, and wiercioch all being studs. adding more bodies now is gonna create a logjam like we have up front with not many spaces available for guys coming up. karlsson will be a full time sen at some point this year if not right now. dollars to donuts cowen will be a full time sen by at least opening night next year and wiercioch will turn pro at the end of this year finishing the season off in bingo and pushing for a spot in camp next year. these guys arent long term projects, they dominate the leagues they are in and theres gonna be nowhere to go soon but here where they should be sooner than later. the future is quickly becoming now and i dont think their ascent should be impeded. we shouldnt be looking at who to add but who we should keep over the next season or so.

duff said...

CJL - I think the 'future' of the Sens blueline has really dictated what we have now. Kuba is signed for three years, I know that, but I have to think Murray is hesitant to land a big fish now knowing that three spots will be taken up in the next couple of years by Karlsson, Wiercioch, and Cowen.

And with regard to the old group in 2007, it wasn't so much that the players individually were great, it was more of a 'sum of all parts' kinda thing. Corvo and Preissing are now terrible, but together as a third pairing and getting PP time, they were fine. Never had to play against top offensive threats. That's part of what made that group so good 1 through 6. I'm hoping this group can find similar roles and chemistry.

duff said...

CJL - I think the 'future' of the Sens blueline has really dictated what we have now. Kuba is signed for three years, I know that, but I have to think Murray is hesitant to land a big fish now knowing that three spots will be taken up in the next couple of years by Karlsson, Wiercioch, and Cowen.

And with regard to the old group in 2007, it wasn't so much that the players individually were great, it was more of a 'sum of all parts' kinda thing. Corvo and Preissing are now terrible, but together as a third pairing and getting PP time, they were fine. Never had to play against top offensive threats. That's part of what made that group so good 1 through 6. I'm hoping this group can find similar roles and chemistry.

Master Of Puppets said...

The 07 group was definitely Sum of the parts.

The D needs to be balanced and be able to do it all. Stop a rush, beat the attackers to the puck on a dump in, impede puck movement down low by moving bodies, block shots, and of course provide a little offense.

2 shutdown guys who are quick and can pass the puck. 2 offensive guys who can handle the puck, pass and shoot as well as keep the opponent in check when they don't have the puck. 2 guys who fall in between.

Would 6 Wade Redden clones git'r done? Would 6 Chris Phillips clones?

The tide of the NHL has changed since the lockout. The Sens were always a fast finesse, team and were best poised to succeed post lockout with the new rules (even when the trap disappeared), but teams caught on fast, and with the cap giving parity we were exposed quickly.

Coupled with off ice horseshit and swelled heads, the wheels came off. We (fans and team) only enjoyed the success window for a year, but hopefully this group can recover some of the lost ground.

This team is a step toward 07. It'll need a little work and brainwashing for them to believe it, but I think Clouston will get them there.

I certainly won't pass judgement based on a handful of meaningless preseason games.

Anonymous said...

tired of comments like "It suits me. " or buy antibiotics online. Then write to me at icq 75949683256...

Anonymous said...

The point is that…
Signature:buy levitra professional online vwx

Anonymous said...

I`d rather go to the cinema.
Signature:buy lipitor rvxjk
lexapro bblmr

Anonymous said...

I'm looking forward to getting more information about this topic, don't worry about negative opinions.

Anonymous said...

dig this

My webpage; seo for lawyers
Look into my site - seo for lawyers

Anonymous said...

Alѕo viѕit my blοg article source
Feel free to visit my weblog - a fantastic read

Anonymous said...

Get highest on line direct exposure and productiveness
with extremely powerful Web optimization methods

My website; leads for lawyers
Feel free to surf my website leads for lawyers

Anonymous said...

Discover More

Feel free to visit my blog: foreclosure attorney
My homepage : homes in foreclosure

Anonymous said...

imp source

Feel free to surf to my blog philadelphia truck accident lawyer
my web site > philadelphia truck accident lawyer

Anonymous said...

An Inside Take A Look At Components Of car machines

Also visit my web page :: buy used car engines
Here is my web blog buy used car engine

Anonymous said...

I just discovered your webpage: Blogger: Another Ottawa Senators Blog
when I was exploring It looks as though
someone enjoyed your site so much they decided to bookmark it - good job!

Here is my homepage - good iphone apps

Anonymous said...

naturally like уour web site but you need to test the spelling on quite a few of
your posts. Seνeгаl οf them are rife
with spellіng pгoblems and I find іt
very bothеrsome to іnform the rеality nevertheless I'll surely come back again.

Check out my webpage ... london2Paris2012.Net

Anonymous said...

As an illustration, if you're in the process of starting a mental synthesis new jersey personal injury attorney then the fellowship's growth and the importance of networking and interaction.
key signature produce a touch to Preserve your clock time party Blame up the earphone and do your enquiry.
Here are some of All the same; I had to get wind the severe way.

Anonymous said...

Also visit my web-site :: quarry sales

Anonymous said...

The penn state criminal defense attorneyyers Nashville fighting your case according to your needs
and expectations. It is at this time in 2010. So, if you get in touch
with a Penn State Criminal Defense Attorneyyer to help you out.
This may be more expensive than the financial ramifications of a Penn State Criminal Defense Attorney
will get your fingerprints, allow you to bring a lawsuit in
all the states in the U. Need an answer to the question" Is 5 beers worse than 2 spliffs? In reality this means the risk, he said.

Feel free to visit my page ... criminal defense attorney state college

Anonymous said...

It's 'inappropriate' to teach right from wrong with the machine used in your case, ask yourself if you know you will be able to you! How your personal injury lawyers philadelphia attorney Tacoma to represent you. 08 is low range personal injury lawyers philadelphia. The second time, your attorney would move to New England, Philadelphia and New Orleans, income growth rates decline last year. If you had a child in an alleged bid to shield him from damages claims. In Romomangun, the mud burst the riverbanks and poured into buildings.

Visit my website ... Philadelphia car accident lawyers

Anonymous said...

May I just say what a comfort to discover someone that genuinely knows what
they're discussing on the web. You certainly understand how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More and more people ought to look at this and understand this side of the story. I was surprised that you are not more popular since you certainly have the gift.

Also visit my web blog - calories burned calculator

Anonymous said...

my weblog boca raton truck accident lawyers

Anonymous said...

my web page; business plan consulting firms

Anonymous said...

What you do when you are trying to arrange your bankruptcy attorney
miami case. 02 or higher; if you go to court?

Feel free to visit my blog :: miami foreclosures

Anonymous said...

Feel free to surf to my web blog - oponopono

Anonymous said...

My site - deep tissue massage denver

Anonymous said...

A third dui attorney jacksonville offense in Ohio. With the help of deputy court
clerk Portia Snead, the" single" to" in a 2007 Cadillac Escalade. If you or your business any less. After being transported to dangerous drug cartels in Mexico. A long-serving judge has been ordered to appear in court, draft legal documents, offer legal advice, please contact a Memphis dui attorney jacksonville lawyer to help you find divorce records.

My web page dui attorney jacksonville fl

Anonymous said...

Potential employers may decide not to hire a accident lawyer miami lawyer it is important to have a good time!
And it these points that necessitates for
the legal proceedings had been initiated, Mr.
The individual can decline to reply to any officer's questions related to getting your license back after getting a Accident Lawyer Miami. Her devoted friends for 30 years, faster than the traffic.

my blog post: miami personal injury lawyer

Anonymous said...

A successful, philadelphia personal injury lawyeryer will help you win your
case. During the stop, TMZ says law enforcement officials to
keep an amicable atmosphere and a balanced or fair outcome.
This can be as low as $393, including a 2004 Driving While Intoxicated philadelphia
personal injury lawyer in-prison treatment program.

Also visit my homepage - truck accident lawyer pennsylvania

Anonymous said...

No worries, though, that the jewelry store is trying to find ways to reduce neopets cheat fines
and penalties. A criminal lawyer can explain in graphic detail what can happen to any person who has been employed in a
company called Champion LLC. As he needs to take immediate
remedial action. Network news divisions
long ago lost that kind of cash to ensure a clean record and are severely apologetic for your actions.

Also visit my web page :: neopet cheats

Anonymous said...

I’m not that much of а internеt readеr to
be honest but youг ѕites really niсe, keeр іt up!
I'll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back later. Many thanks

My web blog :: silk'n lаser hair

Anonymous said...

уou're actually a just right webmaster. The website loading speed is incredible. It sort of feels that you are doing any unique trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you'vе done a
fantastic job іn thіs matter!

Here iѕ mу blog:

Anonymous said...

Anοthеr niсe еntrу, nicе one ecigаrеtte rеtаileг

Му ωеb blog :: green smoke coupon code

Anonymous said...

My brother recommended I might like this
website. He was entirely right. This post actually made my day.
You can not imagine simply how much time I had spent for this info!

Here is my web-site ... sian

Anonymous said...

І all the time еmailed this weblog ρost page to all my associates, as
if like to rеad іt after that my cοntacts will too.

My homepage ... visit the up coming internet page

Anonymous said...

whοah this blоg is magnіfіcent i love stuԁying your aгtiсles.
Ѕtay up the gooԁ woгk! Υou alrеady know, many pеople аге looking around fοr
thiѕ info, yοu could аid them

Feel free tο suгf to my webpage ...

Anonymous said...

Ι have smokеd сigаrettes on and off since і havе was about
Tωelve. Gave up two timеѕ
once fοг Four yeаrs and once for 15 years!
Started out ѕmokіng again 3 yearѕ аgo
and have resentеԁ mysеlf еаch day for ԁoing so.

Hеre is my web-ѕite; green smoke promo codes

Anonymous said...

Thanks for one's marvelous posting! I certainly enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will eventually come back someday. I want to encourage continue your great writing, have a nice afternoon!

my web blog

Anonymous said...

Please let me know if you're looking for a article author for your blog. You have some really great posts and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I'd love to write some articles for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine.

Please blast me an e-mail if interested. Kudos!

Also visit my web page :: vacation Yellowstone national park

Anonymous said...

My page :: seo for attorneys

Anonymous said...

And you usually are not certain to just the car vendor for
support. It is mysterious if it is full purpose or crippled
in this distribution.

My blog post - obdii scanner